BROOKLYN, NY- After a year long hiatus from the stage, FLETCHER returned with the kind of presence that reminds you why she is such a compelling performer. FLETCHER, whose real name is Cari Fletcher, created a space that felt less like a traditional concert and more like being invited into her living room. The stage design and lighting were arranged to resemble her own home, pulling the audience in as if we were close friends welcomed back into her world after time apart.
During her two night, sold out run at the historic Brooklyn Paramount, she turned the venue’s grandeur into something warm and familiar. I was there for the second night, and even in a room filled to the rafters, the experience felt intimate, intentional, and deeply personal. These two intimate shows marked her official return after a year long hiatus, a pause that has clearly reshaped her as both a person and an artist. With the release of her newest album, Would You Still Love Me If You Really Knew Me?, FLETCHER has entered an era that feels both stripped back and sharpened, peeling away the layers of persona and pop polish in favor of something more raw, more reflective, and more true to Cari.
Before this latest chapter, FLETCHER had already carved out a unique place in modern pop. Raised in Asbury Park, New Jersey, she grew up in a place known for producing artists with grit, emotional depth, and a keen sense of storytelling. Even early in her career, she was never the kind of artist who hid behind glossy perfection; instead, she confronted desire, heartbreak, and identity with a refreshing mix of honesty and attitude. Her national breakthrough came with “Undrunk,” a single that catapulted her to a wider audience and earned her a reputation as a rising force capable of turning personal chaos into sharp, melodic pop. Follow-up releases like “Bitter,” her EPs The S(ex) Tapes and You Ruined New York for Me, and her debut full-length Girl of My Dreams further cemented her ability to blend pop clarity with emotional vulnerability. Fans connected not just to her sound, but to the way she welcomed them into her life with the kind of candor that made her music feel lived-in and relatable.
Long known for her alt-pop and pop-rock sensibility, FLETCHER’s new material carries a different weight, and you can hear both the personal and musical evolution she is moving through. Her pop-driven vocals, incisive lyrics, and emotionally charged production are still unmistakable, but now they feel refined and more intentional. The songs play like a letter written across time, part confession to her younger self and part promise to the woman she is becoming. Standing center stage with minimal frills, she delivered each track with a quiet fearlessness and a sharpened new edge, from “Silence,” “Arsonist,” “All Love,” and “Eras of Us” to her breakout hit “Bitter.”
Her growth feels especially striking when remembered alongside her earlier career milestones. From her time competing on television years ago to releasing songs that became queer anthems for young fans searching for reflections of themselves, FLETCHER has always had a gift for transforming personal moments into collective experiences. Her catalog is filled with music that documents both the beautiful and the messy parts of love. Whether singing about the firecracker intensity of desire or the ache of letting go, she cultivated a reputation for honesty. That authenticity wasn’t just branding; it was the thread running through everything she released. The fact that she stepped away for a year makes this return even more meaningful, like watching someone reintroduce themselves with full clarity.
Even after a year long hiatus, it felt as if she had never been away from her fans. In the intimacy of the room, surrounded by the people who have supported her the longest, the night took on a quiet closeness that shaped the entire experience. Throughout the show, FLETCHER paused often to connect with the crowd, sharing pieces of her story with a vulnerability that at times moved her to tears. She spoke openly about the pressures and setbacks she has faced within the music industry, the moments that tested her confidence, and how this album became a place to reclaim herself. The songs reflect a more grounded version of her, one who is learning to be kinder to herself and to love the parts she once questioned.
Looking back, the signs of this shift were already visible. Her most recent projects before her break were moving toward something more introspective. She was writing with sharper honesty, leaning into themes of self-discovery and growth. Still, the decision to pause touring and recenter herself was a pivotal moment. This new record feels like the culmination of that time away. It’s a blueprint for who she is becoming and what she wants her music to hold going forward.
This new era of FLETCHER is not about reinvention for spectacle. It is about evolution, personal, artistic, and emotional. It is about allowing audiences to see Cari, not only the performer known as FLETCHER. With Would You Still Love Me If You Really Knew Me?, she has created her most mature and introspective work to date, and these Brooklyn performances felt like its natural first step into the world. It was clear by the end of the night that we were witnessing an artist stepping fully into her own. Not a comeback, but a return to herself.
Follow FLETCHER on Facebook, TikTok, X, and Instagram.
*********************
LIVE CLIPS
